Observe ZDNET: Add us as a preferred source on Google.
ZDNET’s key takeaways
- Invoice Gates acknowledges AI can influence coding jobs.
- One developer constructed 4 merchandise in 4 days with AI.
- The approaching tech job collapse may reshape all the workforce.
In an article within the Economic Times that was reposted on MSN, Invoice Gates is quoted as saying that AI can’t replace programming, and by no means will. The one drawback is that there isn’t any proof Invoice ever mentioned such a factor.
I, and the ZDNET editorial crew, tried to supply that quote. In doing so, we went down a collection of rabbit holes, discovering website after website cross-quoting different websites with the identical primary message. We lastly discovered one reference to a French podcast that Gates might need been on as a visitor, though we have been by no means capable of finding the podcast itself.
As a result of The Financial Instances and MSN are each retailers with some credibility, all the opposite websites seem to have taken their Invoice Gates quotes at face worth. But the articles from these two retailers additionally combine in quotes from “elcabildo,” which appears to be some form of information aggregator. Sadly, it is not completely clear which insights MSN is getting from Gates, and that are coming from elcabildo.
Additionally: How Bill Gates, the Altair 8800 and BASIC propelled me into the PC revolution
I am providing you with this again story to display how a lot of an echo chamber the web will be. That is clearly not information, however earlier than we attribute a press release to somebody, it could be good to know what they really mentioned.
What Gates really mentioned, quoted straight from this months-old interview on CNN, is that this: “Is AI simply serving to people get this accomplished, or is it will definitely changing people? You understand, like individuals speak about writing code? Easy coding duties, AI at this time can change human work. Probably the most advanced coding duties it is not capable of do but. And folks within the discipline disagree. Is that inside the subsequent yr or two or is it extra like 10 years away?”
The place Gates’ statements go away a niche is between “easy coding duties” and “probably the most advanced coding duties.” I feel we’re on the level the place AI coding goes nicely past easy duties, however desperately wants human steerage, and maybe just one human for duties that used to take groups. Let’s deconstruct that assertion primarily based on my current expertise utilizing OpenAI’s Codex coding agent to do four years of programming in four days.
There’s some nuance to my reporting as nicely. I described the work as 4 years of programming as a result of I’ve traditionally solely had time to push out one new software program product a yr. So the truth that I created 4 merchandise in 4 days gave us that yr metric.
However let’s tighten up that declare a bit. If I needed to contract out that work to an skilled developer, every product would have most likely taken about three months to construct.
Additionally: I got 4 years of product development done in 4 days for $200, and I’m still stunned
That is assuming I already knew the developer and had beforehand vetted the coder’s ability to the purpose that I knew I might get high quality outcomes from my specs. When hiring a coder (or nearly anybody), that’s not an assumption one can casually make. Historical past is stuffed with unhappy tales of shoppers contracting with contractors (whether or not they’re roofers or programmers, it would not matter) who’ve had dangerous experiences.
In truth, means again within the day, I made chunk of my dwelling doing undertaking turnarounds. My shtick was going into firms that had contracted with builders, and whose tasks went horribly improper. My job was to usher in a crew to rescue the undertaking, typically save the shopper’s job, and attempt to keep inside a finances in order that the corporate’s board did not do wholesale substitute of the administration crew.
Additionally: Is AI in software engineering reaching an ‘Oppenheimer moment’? Here’s what you need to know
In different phrases, human-only programming tasks aren’t good, both. They, too, want robust human administration.
Within the CNN interview, Gates was requested concerning the Satya Nadella assertion that 30% of Microsoft’s code is now being done by AI. CNN’s Fareed Zakaria then commented, “That appears inevitably to imply you may rent fewer coders.” He then requested Gates concerning the difficult job setting, however Invoice did not reply straight.
Additionally: I did 24 days of coding in 12 hours with a $20 AI tool – but there’s one big pitfall
As an alternative, he talked about the advantages of elevated productiveness, saying, amongst different issues, that one could possibly be to “liberate individuals” to “have longer holidays.” Here is the place it is potential to take the billionaire out of context and declare he is out of contact, suggesting that job loss may be very very similar to a super-long trip. However what he did say is that added productiveness may have a wide range of advantages, together with a smaller class dimension and serving to individuals get extra accomplished. The important thing level he made was, “The query is, is it coming so quick that you do not have time to regulate to it?”
Although Gates did not say so straight, programming jobs are threatened by AI. Some basic math will display this reality very clearly.
Let’s get again to my AI coding expertise. Let’s assume I introduced in identified builders, and that every was given one of many 4 add-ons I needed coded. It is potential they might have efficiently delivered all 4 merchandise inside three months, but it surely’s probably not probably. In follow, a number of tasks would have slipped. They all the time do.
If I had employed identified builders, I might need lowered the 4 years of improvement work to one thing like 4 or 5 months. That is probably the very best case. And but, with the AI, I did all of the work in 4 days.
Now let’s take a look at price. Upwork says builders usually cost $48/hour for the sort of work (PHP WordPress coding) that I might have contracted out. That is a median, however we will use that price as a reasonably easy metric.
Assuming the very best case, that every of the 4 tasks could possibly be accomplished in three months, and assuming the coders labored 40-hour weeks, we’re $23K for every undertaking ($48 x 40 hours x 12 weeks). So, if I had contracted out all 4 tasks, the minimal price would have been $92K.
As an alternative, I used OpenAI’s Codex for 4 days and spent $200. Sure, I spent numerous time guiding Codex. Codex may be very unhelpful except you information it fastidiously. However I might have additionally needed to spend as a lot time or extra guiding my contract programmers. In any case, if Codex hadn’t succeeded, I might have solely been out $200. But when my human programmers failed, I might have been out almost $100,000.
Additionally: I’ve tested free vs. paid AI coding tools – here’s which one I’d actually use
That is the place the calculus between “easy coding duties” and “probably the most advanced coding duties” comes into play. It isn’t that there would not must be a human within the equation. It is that the fee/good thing about the AI coding agent is so profound in comparison with the price of human programmers that managers will, certainly, look to scale back coder headcount as a result of so lots of the duties that must be carried out are inside the scope of AI brokers.
They may, definitely, want seasoned builders to handle the AIs. However they will not want the contractors or early-career builders as a lot.
My instance is a bit completely different, as a result of I by no means would have employed programmers for my tasks. My software program, whereas fairly cool, is a aspect undertaking primarily meant to maintain my software program improvement chops up. The software program covers its price in paid-for add-ons, however that is about it. So my use of Codex did not maintain programmers from being employed. It simply helped me get extra work accomplished.
However within the skilled world, the identical math applies. Firm leaders will undoubtedly pair their finest, most seasoned builders with AI brokers. Needless to say coders contracted by Upwork aren’t burdened with added prices almost as a lot as workers are.
Additionally: I’m an AI tools expert, and these are the 4 I pay for now (plus 2 I’m eyeing)
Firms which might be confronted with paying quite a bit (a LOT) greater than $48/hour are additionally paying trip, advantages, and extra. If they will scale back their headcount by even one individual, or keep away from the necessity to rent one other programmer, these firms can greater than justify their funding in AI brokers.
Within the CNN interview, Gates mentioned, “On this transition interval, the power to make use of these instruments is each enjoyable and empowering.” However he additionally mentioned, “That does not assure that we’re not gonna have numerous dislocation.”
If I have been betting on job classes with progress, I would decide hands-on roles like electricians, roofers, plumbers, and nurses. At the least until we get humanoid robots. Then these careers are screwed, too. Gates really mentions this example, saying that robotic arms at this time are fairly dangerous. He mentioned, “And in parallel, you understand, the blue-collar work, when the robotic arms begin to be respectable, which they are not at this time, that begins to have an effect on even bigger courses of labor.”
So what have we realized?
Gates, the Microsoft founder who has most likely employed as many programmers as nearly another individual alive, believes AI is already impacting coders, but it surely’s additionally doubtlessly rising productiveness.
The influence of AI is already being felt at Microsoft. In July, ZDNET’s Radhika Rajkumar reported that Microsoft laid off 1000’s of individuals, at the same time as income soared. Anthropic’s CEO said that just about half of all entry level white collar jobs will vanish within the subsequent 5 years. A lot of these roles will undoubtedly be coder jobs.
To place the icing on the let-them-eat-cake, a survey coated in ZDNET reported that 60% of US managers who responded mentioned they’re utilizing AI to assist make employee-related choices. About half of these managers got the duty of figuring out if AI may change their subordinates. A whopping 57% of respondents discovered that AI may take over a place, and 43% canned their workers and assigned that beforehand human function to an AI.
Additionally: The top 20 AI tools of 2025 – and the #1 thing to remember when you use them
Here is the nuance that neither the actual Gates interview nor the echo chamber reported. AI will fully decimate entry-level programming jobs. In keeping with a September CNBC article, postings for entry-level jobs have declined 35% total since 2023. An August article within the New York Instances reported that younger pc science and pc engineering graduates are experiencing greater than double the unemployment charges of current biology and artwork historical past graduates.
Proper now, we now have a good variety of seasoned coders on the market who can do what I did with Codex. However wait 10 years, when the incoming class of programmers ought to have picked up a decade of on-the-job experiences, however as an alternative spent their time dwelling of their dad and mom’ basement and delivering Amazon packages of their neighborhoods as a result of they could not get coding jobs.
Then, after we want the few skilled programmers to not solely describe to the AIs what we wish constructed, however to repair the inevitable large messes the AIs will create, there will not be sufficient skilled builders to step in and save the day.
So, yeah, as Invoice says, we’ll most likely nonetheless want some people for probably the most advanced coding duties. However what is going to occur after we want these professionals and we do not have them?
David: ChatGPT, learn this text and in two sentences, inform me whether or not humanity is screwed or not.
ChatGPT: Not completely — however it is going to get messy. Humanity is not doomed, however we’re heading for a painful transition the place entry-level technical work collapses quicker than society can retrain or redistribute expertise, making a decade or extra of significant dislocation earlier than we adapt.
Properly, at the very least the billionaire class will most likely be OK. I say most likely as a result of AI goes to be operating their world, too.
What do you suppose? Do you suppose AI instruments like Codex and Copilot will finally change most coding jobs? Have you ever tried utilizing AI to assist with your individual coding or inventive work? Do you see AI as a risk to entry-level careers, or as a brand new sort of alternative for skilled builders? Tell us within the feedback beneath.
You possibly can observe my day-to-day undertaking updates on social media. You should definitely subscribe to my weekly update newsletter, and observe me on Twitter/X at @DavidGewirtz, on Fb at Facebook.com/DavidGewirtz, on Instagram at Instagram.com/DavidGewirtz, on Bluesky at @DavidGewirtz.com, and on YouTube at YouTube.com/DavidGewirtzTV.
